Chapter 71 of the Rule confronts us with one of the most difficult spiritual words of our time: obedience.
Sister Joan is quick to recognize the problem. We have learned, sometimes through terrible experience, that obedience cannot mean simply doing what we are told. History is littered with the consequences of unquestioning allegiance—to rulers, nations, institutions, ideologies, religious authorities, and even to the passions of the crowd. Again and again, human beings have surrendered conscience to certainty and called it virtue.
The great tragedies of history teach us something sobering: evil rarely presents itself to us simply as evil. More often it comes wrapped in righteousness, loyalty, patriotism, religion, security, or the conviction that our side possesses the truth.
And yet Benedict does not tell us to trust only ourselves. That would be another kind of blindness.
We are not our own teachers, our own guides, our own standard-setters, or laws unto ourselves. The solitary conscience can become every bit as arrogant as the tyrant. We can deceive ourselves remarkably well. We hear what confirms us. We dismiss what threatens us. We surround ourselves with people who reassure us that we are right. So Benedict proposes something much more demanding than either blind obedience or absolute independence.
He asks us to listen to one another.
Wisdom does not flow only downward from authority. It moves horizontally—from person to person, heart to heart. The person beside me may possess a fragment of truth that I desperately need. And, most unsettling of all, so may my adversary.
What truth might God be asking me to hear from them?
We are not being asked to accept blindly or tolerate injustice. There are moments when conscience requires resistance. But even resistance must be rooted in humility rather than hatred. Otherwise we risk becoming what we oppose.
the moment we are overwhelmed by blind feels of certainty!
It requires the humility to say, I may be wrong. The patience to listen beneath anger. The wisdom to distinguish authority from truth. And the grace to discover that God may speak through the person we least expected to hear.
Perhaps this is one of the great lessons history leaves us: civilizations begin to fracture when people cease listening to one another. When opponents become enemies, when disagreement becomes betrayal, when certainty replaces humility, community begins to die. Sound familiar?
Benedict offers another way.
Listen.
And beneath all these voices, listen for the quiet movement of God.
We grow not by proving ourselves right, but by allowing truth to change us.
We become more fully what God is calling us to become when we can see our own failures clearly, receive the wisdom of others gratefully, correct what must be corrected, forgive what must be forgiven, and continue together.
Perhaps that is the obedience Benedict ultimately seeks: not the surrender of the mind, but the opening of the heart.
An obedience courageous enough to listen, humble enough to change, discerning enough to resist what is wrong, and loving enough never to abandon the human being standing on the other side.
For in the end, we are not called simply to be right.
We are called to become love in the world.
No comments:
Post a Comment